Petitioners were seeking to win a bid from the us department of transportation for a highway project. Mountain gravel then hired gonzales as a subcontractor. Federal agency contracts provide a clause that gives financial incentives to contractors that hire minorityowned small businesses to do subcontracting work. Permission to publish or otherwise reproduce the logo of the association of american universities aau is granted on a onetime basis only for the purpose of the use on the front of the report navigating a complex landscape to foster greater faculty. Pena a 1995 supreme court decision holding that federal programs that classify people by race, even for an ostensibly benign purpose such as expanding opportunities for minorities, should be presumed to be unconstitutional. Nixon, president of the united states asses the united kingdoms reasons for supporting the united states over the invasion of iraq in 2003 adarand construction inc. Adarand v pena case brief natasha n bailey proc 5890 title.
Pena is a case that was decided by the united states supreme court in 1995. Adarand, a contractor specializing in highway guardrail work, submitted the lowest bid as a subcontractor for part of a project funded by the united. Adarand v pena case brief natasha n bailey proc 5890. All racial classifications, imposed by whatever federal, state, or local. The armageddon of affirmative action introduction the battle over affirmative action is currently raging in both the legal and political arenas.
Adarand constructors inc v pena term paper warehouse. Adarand construction v pena brief rita kim facts issue rule. Adarand lost by summary judgment in both the district court and the court of appeals. The supreme court held that racial classifications. Adarand constructors, a nondisadvantaged highway construction company, challenged the sturaa setaside after its low bid for a guardrail subcontracting.
Justice sandra day oconnor wrote the majority opinion of the court, which effectively. They line our nations highways and byways, standing as sentinels and guides to the roadside hazards of a country constantly on the move. Rita kim november 17, 2014 adarand constructors, inc. Posted on october 31, 2012 constitutional law tags. Gonzales won, despite the fact that another subcontractor, adarand, submitted a lower bid. The bid was given to mountain gavel construction, who then sought bids for subcontractors. The age discrimination in employment act in particular, the act protects workers over forty years of age and prohibits forced retirement in. Pena, 1995 and limited the scope of desegregation of the schools and the equal protection clause see, for example, freeman v. Both courts felt that the recent supreme court rulings in. Joel dufresne was falsely convicted of csc charges against angela w, the mother of his child in emmet county, mi. Adarand, a contractor specializing in highway guardrail work, submitted the lowest bid as a subcontractor for part of a project funded by the united states department of transportation. Justice sandra day oconnor wrote the majority opinion of the court, which effectively overturned metro broadcasting, inc. Though the court has cut back some fourth and fifth amendment rights, limited the reach of affirmative action adarand constructors, inc.
Adarand construction v pena brief rita kim facts issue. As this case worked its way through the federal courts prior to the grant of certiorari that brought it here, petitioner adarand constructors, inc. The bid was given to mountain gravel, who then looked for bids for subcontractual workers. Justice oconnor delivered an opinion with respect to parts i, page ii ii, iiia, iiib, iiid, and iv, which was for the court except insofar as it might be inconsistent with the.
The second case, i have to announce comes to us from the united states court of appeals for the tenth circuit. District court for the district of colorado against secretary of transportation frederico pena and other federal officials, claiming that the racebased presumptions used in subcontractor compensation clauses. It was a way to remedy the inequality that has typically favored whiteowned businesses. The principles of equal protection embody some of the most deeply cherished ideals of americanism that all persons are to be treated equally under the law, entitled to the same freedoms and rights, and deserving of the same opportunities. This memorandum sets forth preliminary legal guidance on the implications of the supreme courts recent decision in adarand constructors, inc. The united states supreme court attempted to resolve this conflict with its decision in adarand constructors, inc. Such lawsuits have added a new dimension to the traditional roberts analysis. The court of appeals for the tenth circuit affirmed. Adarand constructors is a colorado company that lost a federal. The restrictions mainly focus on federal presumption of socially and economic disadvantages which developed from past discriminating. It held the district court mistakenly determined the challenged program was authorized by staa and sturaa, whereas, as stipulated for the purposes of the appeal, the scc program is authorized by 502 of the sba, 15 u. The syllabus constitutes no part of the opinion of the court but has been prepared by the reporter of decisions for the convenience of the reader. Audio transcription for oral argument january 17, 1995 in adarand constructors, inc.
The court held that strict scrutiny, not intermediate scrutiny, is the correct test to use when determining if a racebased classification imposed by a federal government agency violates the equal protection standard of the fifth amendment. If it is the individual who is entitled to judicial protection against classifications based upon his racial or ethnic. Get exclusive access to content from our 1768 first edition with your subscription. No area in american life is more volatile than the point at which charges of racial injustice intersect with the administration of criminal law kennedy, 1997. They line our nations highways and byways, standing as sentinels and guides to the roadside hazards of a. They are an everyday part of the american landscape. Bailey proc 5890 title and citation adarand constructors, inc. Under the terms of the federal contract, the prime contractor would receive additional compensation if it hired small businesses controlled by socially and. Pena audio transcription for opinion announcement june 12, 1995 in adarand constructors, inc. Justice stewart gave no indication that he thought he was addressing a novel proposition, post at. A summary and case brief of adarand constructors, inc. Whether the petitioners right were violated under the equal protection clause of the fifth amendment when it was not awarded a subcontract to build guardrails, even though it submitted a lower bid than a subcontractor certified as a small business controlled by socially and economically disadvantaged individuals. Argued january 17, 1995decided june 12, 1995 most federal agency contracts must contain a subcontractor compensation clause, which gives a prime contractor a. Pesh, cofounder of adarand construction company, discussed the events behind the supreme court case of adarand v.
See maguire, supra note 20, at vii prefacing his book by commenting on the. The district court granted respondents summary judgment. Legal guidance on the implications of the supreme courts. History of affirmative action american association for.
Justice oconnor announced the judgment of the court and delivered an opinion with respect to parts i, ii, iiia, iiib, iiid, and iv, which is for the court except insofar as it might be inconsistent with the views expressed in justice scalias concurrence, and an opinion with respect to part. Racial trends in the administration of criminal justice. The restrictions mainly focus on federal presumption of socially and economic. Gonzales won, despite the fact that another subcontractor, adarand, submitted a. The case at hand involved subcontractor compensation clauses in federal agency contracts, where 1 such clauses generally provided that a general or prime contractor would receive additional compensation for hiring subcontractors certified as small businesses owned and controlled by socially and economically disadvantaged individuals. It was upheld in the district court and the circuit court of appeals but was overturned by the supreme court. Adarand, a contractor specializing in highway guardrail work, submitted the. Adarand constructors, a company owned and operated by a white male submitted a proposal for a project at the lowest. Court decision that made use of a lenient standard, resem.
1007 1320 129 632 982 961 336 1187 1161 1058 448 87 132 968 569 272 642 1494 78 693 468 562 1101 80 833 312 61 30 1064 1165 880 1354 1400 422 314 95 620